HDC, Regular Historic District Commission Meeting

Last time I welcomed @MichiganRadio to the #DETdocumenters team and this time I’m welcoming @wxyzdetroit — our first television partner. Learn more about the collaboration below.
outliermedia.org/wxyz-joins-det…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 3/52

If you’re interested in joining the meeting or want to learn more about the Historic Detroit Commission visit their website.
detroitmi.gov/departments/pl…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 4/52

We're starting the meeting at 5:36 p.m.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 5/52

Most of today’s meeting will be the commission reviewing applications for changes to the exterior of homes located in historic districts. Here’s more information on the commission's process.
detroitmi.gov/departments/pl…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 6/52

I’ll be posting direct links to the city’s website about each project being reviewed, but I also recommend you check out this cool map. Type in any address to see if it’s in a historic district.
detroitmi.gov/webapp/local-h…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 7/52

New commissioners Andrea Simmons and Najahyia Chinchilla introduced themselves. Simmons is attending virtually, but not voting, due to a prior commitment. They both live in Historic Districts.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 8/52

The first application under review is 15083 Minock St, located in the Rosedale Park Historic District.
detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 9/52

What's in question with the 15083 Minock property is the size of the addition and how it compares to other homes in the neighborhood.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 10/52

This isn't the first time the Minock street project has been reviewed. Commissioners have made several comments that this new presentation took into account their last critiques.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 11/52

The 15083 Minock application is approved by the commission.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 12/52

The next application under review is 2285 Atkinson detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 13/52

The applicants seek to build a detached garage at the home. The plan is for the garage to have vinyl siding, but the commission would like it to be built with a material that better fits the historic district.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 14/52

The next project under review is 269 Watson in the Brush Park Historic District
detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 15/52

Historic District Staff has noted several compliance issues with work being completed before approval from the commission. The staff finds the work does not meet secretary interior standards because it altered the homes original features.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 16/52

Work completed in violation of the Historic Commission includes removing a garage, reconstructing a side porch, and installing a fence.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 17/52

The reason given to the historic commission by a woman representing the property owner is that he wanted to complete the work before the cold weather.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 18/52

This project has been denied due to changes that alter home's original features, specifically its porch.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 19/52

Work to complete the fence and downspouts following the commissions alterations to the project was approved

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 20/52

The next application under review is 1427 Randolph in the Madison Harmonie Historic District
detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 21/52

The commissions main criticism is the proposed airlock of that would be constructed on the exterior of the building. You'd enter the small vestibule before continuing through a door to the rest of the building. This application was approved 3-2.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 22/52

The next application is 1407 Randolph, right next door to 1427 Randolph and the same owner. detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 23/52

This application was approved.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 24/52

The next application under review is 1133 & 1145 Griswold St
detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 25/52

This is project was approved. It's an extensive rehabilitation of the building.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 26/52

The next project under review is 2905 Garland, the Ossian Sweet House.
detroitmi.gov/departments/ge…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 27/52

Here's the complete project for rehabilitation of the Ossian Sweet House.
detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 28/52

A Historic District staff member said this project is a focus of Mayor Duggan and something he hopes to see completed by the end of the year.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 29/52

Alex Grabowski is working on the project for the city and said he's honored to be a part of rehabilitating this historic home.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 30/52

The Sweet home has an enclosed side porch and the Historic District has made an effort to determine if this was original to the home or a later addition.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 31/52

The Ossian Sweet House project is approved.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 32/52

Now we're reviewing the application for 2200 (2600) East Atwater Street, better known as the Aretha Franklin Amphitheater
detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 33/52

The original plan presented would have removed a large area of pine trees at the amphitheater. They'll only be removing younger trees that are being impacted by disease.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 34/52

Vegetation and plants will be introduced that were original to the amphitheater's design.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 35/52

The proposed project would remove cement pylons with signs that give directions around the venue. These would be replace with larger pylons and new signing.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 36/52

A new project will replace windows at the amphitheater's administration building. This was approved by the commission.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 37/52

We've now moved onto the part of the meeting that involves projects not subject to public hearing. The first project being presented is 761 Whitmore Street. detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 38/52

The 761 Whitmore Project was approved.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 39/52

We're on to 7908-7912 St. Paul detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 40/52

The owner seeks to replace windows in the home but a closer review of their condition is recommended by the Historic District staff. The project was approved with conditions set by the commission.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 41/52

Now under review is 511 Woodward. This was a late addition and added to an updated agenda. Here's the project that was approved.
detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 42/52

We're now looking at 2475 Chicago and the owner is looking to replace windows in the home.
detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 43/52

Commission is recommending an expert look at the window to see if they can be winterized. The owner thinks repairing the window is an "excessive demand" opposed to replacing them.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 44/52

"These windows look repairable to me and we've yet to see a cost estimate from an expert," a commissioner said regarding the proposed project.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 45/52

We've now entered a spirited conversation over preserving windows. After a several minute long back and forth with the owner, he was advised by a commissioner to stop interrupting the board or he'd be asked to leave. https://t.co/kI5nhYFomV

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 46/52

The project for 2475 Chicago St was denied.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 47/52

Vinyl window signs will be added at 267 E. Grand River detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 48/52

The last project is 1652 Edison and it was approved. detroitmi.gov/government/may…

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 49/52

Commissioner Tiffany Franklin was unanimously approved as chair and Commissioner Allan Machielse as vice chair.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 50/52

The meeting is adjourned at 9:57 pm.

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 51/52

I'm signing off on my end! Thanks for following along. Is something inaccurate? Email documenters@outliermedia.org with the subject “Correction Request.”

Jack Filbrandt @JackFilbrandt 52/52

As always, check out all the other work and reporting from @DetDocumenters! detroit.documenters.org

View thread

Attachments

Transcript and recording

By Noah Kincade 3/8/2023

Agency Information

Detroit Historic District Commission

(313) 224-3487

See Documenters reporting

The purpose of the Historic District Commission is to ensure the preservation of historically and culturally significant areas of the City which are designated by the City Council as Historic Districts.